School Breaks New Ground For Natatorium
The Grand Haven project is the culmination of many original hvac design concepts developed and implemented at previous indoor swimming pool projects by an engineering team from GMB Architects-Engineers (Holland, MI). Led by project mechanical engineer James Harrison, GMB’s innovations at Grand Haven include a unique split return air design. Additionally, the school district realized a substantial cost savings in labor and materials because GMB specified one of the world’s largest dehumidifiers, which was custom manufactured by indoor air quality equipment manufacturer Dectron Internationale (Roswell, GA).
“One of primary goals in the construction of the aquatic center was to have a facility that not only met the needs of our swimming and recreation programs, but also created a comfortable, healthy environment for spectators,” said Rick Kent, superintendent, Grand Haven Area Public Schools. “Our aquatic center has exceeded all these goals.”
Swimming Against TraditionTypical natatorium designs use one large wall grille to collect return air, but GMB has found that this method may not adequately promote air movement to all areas of a large pool room. At Grand Haven, the design team used the standard wall grille for only 50% of the return air. Air movement is substantially increased because the remaining return air is collected with air inlets under concrete bench seating on two sides of the facility. An aluminum duct combined with a concrete tunnel under the pool deck serves the bench grilles. “Because our supply air is high at the ceiling level, we used 50% of the return air to help draw it down to the participant and spectator level,” said Harrison. “With the single return air wall grille method we’ve seen at other natatoriums, there’s too much air stratification, which leads to indoor air discomfort. We’ve used this return air design on two other natatoriums. Based on the owner/occupant responses, it’s really the best way to go.”
GMB broke tradition with other natatorium hvac design concepts as well. Typically an indoor pool dehumidifier is in a mechanical room or rooftop location. At Grand Haven however, the dehumidifier is located outside at ground level to save upwards of $30,000 in mechanical room sq footage and eliminate what may have resulted in an unsightly installation on the facility’s aesthetic, barrel-shaped roof. Since part of the return air is underground in the pool area, Rite-Way Plumbing & Heating (Grand Rapids, MI) kept the return ductwork underground en route to the dehumidifier for aesthetic purposes. The underground return air enters the dehumidifier via a base configuration and curb plenum – a custom modification specified by GMB. The challenge with an underground duct installation, according to Larry Heemstra, project manager, Rite-Way Plumbing & Heating, was digging the trench deep enough and then structurally supporting the walls to protect workers against dangerous cave-ins.
A Humidifier for Every SeasonTypically a project of this size requires several dehumidifiers working in tandem. However GMB broke convention again by taking advantage of Dectron’s custom manufacturing advantages. GMB specified one of the largest dehumidifiers on the market manufactured by Dectron, a Dry-O-Tron® RS-362 with airflow of 64,000 cfm and a moisture removing capacity of 377 lbs/hr. GMB’s design also provides 1⁄2-cfm of outside air/sq ft of deck and pool area, which is sufficient for the natatorium’s 1,000 spectator capacity. The 23-ft-long unit saved the school district thousands of dollars vs. the costs of installing, piping, and ducting two or three units, not to mention saving limited ground area outside the natatorium.
“I approached Paul McWatters (sales engineer at MacAire Inc. (Grand Haven, MI), a manufacturer’s representative for Dectron) to see if Dectron could custom build one really large unit and they came through,” said Harrison.
GMB also designed a supply air distribution system that is visually unnoticeable because it follows the contours of the natatorium’s architectural, barrel-shaped ceiling. While the ductwork adds an aesthetic touch, sheet metal subcontractor, Superior Sheet Metal (Rockford, MI) found it challenging to install.
Manufactured by Eastern Sheet Metal (Cincinnati), the galvanized and epoxy-coated spiral ductwork needed dozens of elbows ranging from 15 to 22 degrees to maintain a constant 12-in. gap along the contoured ceiling. “Installing the ceiling ductwork was very challenging and required super accurate field measurements,” said Jerry Marculis, estimator/coordinator, Superior Sheet Metal. While the Dry-O-Tron dehumidifies and heats the pool water, it also reduces the space heating load in the winter via efficient heat recovery from the exhaust air and preheating of the outdoor air. Space heating is handled by the building’s hot water heating system comprised of two Lochinvar Corp. (Nashville, TN) 2,618-MBtuh input boilers that supply a Taco, Inc. (Cranston, RI) 1,575-MBtuh, 158-gpm secondary heat exchanger via a 1.5-hp Taco pump.
Besides the main pool, the facility also has a separate, 2,000-sq-ft therapy pool room that features a 15-ft-high, 25-ft-high wide wall of windows. Keeping the windows free of condensation was another design challenge for GMB. Neither the area between the ceiling and the windows nor a pool deck diffuser system would provide ample window coverage. Instead, air was supplied from two 12-in. round column ducts that appear aesthetically as support columns on each side of the windows.
Even though Grand Haven is a small town of 15,000 people, it now has a big time pool that attracts many local swimming programs and competitions.ES