Location, Location, Location
Energy savings in fan and pump installations employing vfd's and using closed loop control with pressure feedback can be significant. These potential savings are the justification for the purchase and installation of drives. Advancements in vfd technology continually induce businesses to "spend in order to save."
Realizing that potential, however, has often proven to be elusive, due to the inherent dependency for success on proper placement of the pressure feedback transmitter in the air or water distribution system.
Many in our industry can recall projects where extensive efforts in the design and installation of state-of-the-art, vfd-based, energy-conserving systems failed to produce the anticipated economies.
Pressure Transmitter LocationIt is the location of the pressure transmitter that will determine the degree to which actual energy savings occurs.
Cryptic recommendations are made regarding transmitter location "two-thirds of the distance" out in the distribution system or "at significant loads." But why are these locations suggested? The reasons need broader explanation if we are to expect these rules of thumb to be followed by system designers and installers.
The equation for power required by a fan or pump is:
Power = (Flow x Pressure)/Efficiency
From this equation, one can see that reduction in either flow or pressure will contribute to a reduction in power. Furthermore, reduction in both flow and pressure should provide the most power reduction.
Flow reduction occurs because it is directly modulated by the hvac system control valves or dampers in response to applied load changes. As flow decreases, from design flow, so does system resistance to that flow. Therefore, less pressure is needed from the fan or pump when it is operating under partial-load conditions.
Measure Pressure At The LoadTo benefit from lower flow resistance, it is essential to place the transmitter so that it measures pressure where the load is located - in the distribution system extremities. This pressure is critical to control performance. It allows the drive's PID controller to take advantage of the decreased resistance to flow in the distribution network as flow is reduced.
With this pressure transmitter placement, as in Figure 1, the controller setpoint requirement is the actual pressure needed by the load. There is no necessity for a controller setpoint based on the worst case scenario of maximum load, maximum pressure conditions.
Some installations have incorrectly located the pressure transmitter directly at the pump or fan discharge, as in Figure 2, usually to reduce installation costs or take advantage of standard equipment packages offered by OEMs. A pressure transmitter at this location will ignore much of the potential for energy savings.
Location Affects Energy ConservationThe significance of transmitter location for energy conservation in pressure control applications is not always obvious to the people involved - system designers, drive application engineers, installation technicians, and mechanical engineers. Further explanation may be required to accommodate other viewpoints:
The ConceptLocation of the transmitter at the optimum distance in the distribution system allows use of a lower controller setpoint. This setpoint reduction provides improved energy performance. Both flow and pressure impact the power required. Therefore, the control strategy must optimize both the flow and pressure that the pump or fan is required to deliver.
The DetailsThe system pressure required at the furthest significant load is constant, regardless of load changes. It is the pressure necessary to maintain design flow through a load device and control valve or damper that is open to handle design load in the conditioned space.
In order to deliver this pressure and flow, the pump or fan must be capable of overcoming the system resistance to flow. System resistance, for much of the flow range, is likely to be a more significant pressure consideration than that of the load device.
As flow to the load increases, pump or fan discharge pressure must be high enough to overcome increasing system resistance. Maximum system flow, therefore, requires the highest pump or fan discharge pressure to overcome system resistance and still deliver the required flow.
If the pressure transmitter is located near a pump or fan discharge, as in Figure 2, the controller setpoint must be established at this worst-case high discharge pressure to ensure that there will be enough pressure at the load when the flow is greatest. At all other (lower) flows, there will be more pressure than necessary at the loads.
The controller setpoint is a single value, so if the pressure transmitter is located at the pump or fan discharge, it must be set at a high level - the system design pressure. Such a high controller setpoint ignores significant potential energy savings that would be produced by variable flow with variable pressure at the pump or fan discharge.
Alternatively, if the pressure transmitter is located at the furthest significant load in the distribution system, as in Figure 1, the controller setpoint can be established at the much lower pressure required by the load. In this case, as the flow is reduced by control valves or dampers, the pump or fan only needs to maintain the lower pressure requirements of the load.
As flow decreases and system resistance lessens, pump or fan discharge pressure will also decrease by the same amount as the falloff in system resistance to flow. In this control scheme the pump or fan discharge pressure is uncontrolled while the pressure that is important to system operation is under closed-loop control.
Improved ConservationEnergy conservation improves with the pressure transmitter at the extremities of the distribution system, as in Figure 1, because this location for the transmitter allows the drive PID controller to utilize a lower setpoint. This means that system pressure at the control valves or dampers will never be more than is required. The potential for energy savings, resulting from variable flow with variable pressure, will be realized because the pump or fan discharge pressure will be able to decrease as flow decreases.
When the transmitter is located at the pump or fan discharge, as in Figure 2, the ability to sense what is happening in the system is lost. To prepare for the worst case (full flow) condition, the control system always must provide design pressure at the pump or fan discharge.
With the transmitter "out in the system" at the loads, as in Figure 1, discharge pressure is allowed to vary as needed. This is a "smart" system because the controls automatically adapt to variations in distribution system resistance to flow occurring with changes in flow rates. The lower the controller setpoint relative to the design pressure of the pump of fan, the less power that is required.
Summing UpThis single detail of system design for application of drives to hvac fans and pumps can significantly impact energy performance, such as improving from 5% savings for the inefficient transmitter location in Figure 2 to a 30% (or more) savings for the proper transmitter location in Figure 1. ES
Transmitter Location Drives Savings: Definition of TermsClosed Loop - Control of output by comparison of a feedback signal to a setpoint. The feedback signal provided by a transmitter closes the loop between a controller, controlled device, and controlled variable. Also commonly referred to as "PID control."
Design Point - The maximum load, flow, or pressure that the distribution system is designed to handle.
Discharge Pressure - Pressure measured at, or very close to, a pump or fan discharge.
Distribution System - The piping or ductwork that distributes water or air in an hvac system.
Feedback - The standard signal provided to a drive's PID controller by the transmitter and its wiring.
Load - A device that can demand flow of air or water. In pump applications, they are a coil and control valve. In fan applications, it is a terminal unit damper.
PID - Proportional plus Integral plus Derivative control.
Terminal Unit - For the purposes of this article, it is the device at the end of the distribution system with flow modulation capability, a vav box or a cooling coil and control valve.
Transmitter - A device that generates a standard signal proportional to an analog pressure input. In the applications described above, the transmitter is usually a differential pressure transmitter in pumping applications and a static pressure transmitter in fan applications. For pumping applications, the pressure measured is the difference in pressure across the control valve and coil at the preferred transmitter location.
Setpoint - The pressure that the drive's PID controller maintains at the transmitter location.