Engineered Systems
  Home
  Subscribe
  eNewsletters
  Online
  Web Features
  Webinars
  Podcasts
  Blog
  White Papers
  Products
  Current Issue
  Cover Story
  Features
  Columns
  Case In Point
  Issues and Events
  Departments
  Letters to the Editor
  Green Intelligent Buildings Supplement
  ES Glossary
  Calendar of Events
  HVAC Challenge
  HVAC Designer Tips
  Product Info(Free)
  Resources
  Archives
  Digital Edition Archives
  Career Center
  Back2Basics
  Mechanical Products Sourcebook
  Industry Links
  Market Research
  PennWell Books
  ES Info
Search in: EditorialProductsCompanies
Hydro Tech: Swiss Cheese Pump Impeller
by John Kuempel Jr. P.E.
October 1, 2008

ARTICLE TOOLS
EmailEmailPrintPrintReprintsReprintsshareShareshare Use

&nbsp;pump impeller<br>


Don’t let cavitation put holes in your performance.

This is the real deal. This pump impeller was removed from a six-month-old condenser water filtration installation.  The bronze casting is almost completely gone.  The impeller blades are deteriorated like swiss cheese.  The pump flange casting even has complete erosion through _ in.-thick material. 

Pump selection must be particularly careful when the pressure and temperature of the water entering the pump can reach the vapor pressure of the fluid.  When the absolute pressure at the pump surface approaches the vapor pressure, vapor pockets form in the impeller passages.  As the pressure increases, these vapor pockets collapse and are destructive to the surrounding materials.  The collapse of vapor pockets is called cavitation.

Cavitation is noisy and sounds likes marbles in the pump.  It is easy to identify.  Extreme cases left uncorrected can cause severe destruction ”— just look at the pictures. Typically, if the pump is incorrectly selected, the only solution is to switch to a different pump.  In some cases, the pump flow can be reduced by closing a discharge valve, but system performance may be compromised.

To prevent cavitation, pumps should be selected with the correct net positive suction head required (NPSHR). This pressure, published by the pump manufacturer, is the point above which there will be pressure to prevent formation of vapor pockets. NPSHR will vary with a given pump for different flows and pump speeds.  It is typically included on the pump performance curve.

Systems where particular attention to pump selection to prevent cavitation is necessary include condenser tower applications, steam condensate return pumps, steam boiler feed pumps, and other open systems.  Closed heating and cooling piping systems are generally not a problem as the fill pressure can be set to increase pump suction above the required NPSHR.

The next time you have a pump that sounds like it has marbles in it — remember these pictures. ES



John Kuempel Jr. P.E.
Kuempel is vice president of design-build for DeBra-Kuempel, an EMCOR company providing HVAC, electrical, plumbing, automation, service, and maintenance in the Cincinnati and Dayton Ohio area.



Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to the magazine.
BNP Media